」工欲善其事,必先利其器。「—孔子《論語.錄靈公》
首頁 > 程式設計 > 無需媒體查詢的響應式佈局

無需媒體查詢的響應式佈局

發佈於2024-11-08
瀏覽:593

How often do you use media queries when building web layouts? I’ve spent too much time on them!

First you spent quite a lot of time trying to make the layout exactly like in the design. But then you need to resize your browser to all possible screen resolutions to make sure your page still looks good on all of them. And I mean to resize not only by width, but by height too - especially, if you have full height sections.

Eventually, your CSS become full of lines like these:

@media screen and (max-width: 1199px) { /*styles here*/ }
@media screen and (max-width: 1023px) { /*more styles here*/ }
@media screen and (max-width: 767px) { /*another styles here*/ }

And that’s annoying! Won’t it be much easier if you can include responsiveness kind of like automatically? Of course, you still need to provide the rules for the responsiveness, but without need to write them for dozens of screen resolutions.

Units system

The first thing you need to understand about responsive design is that you have to forget about pixels.

I know it might be hard to switch from one unit to another, but using pixels is the voice from the past.

The biggest problem with using pixels as a size unit is that you don’t get in count the user's device from which it views your website.

The default root font size for modern browsers is 16px. That means 1rem = 16px. But that doesn't mean users cannot change that value in browser settings to whatever they want.

So imagine the user's default browser font size is 24px. But you setted up the font size of the body tag to 16px.

Here’s what user expects to see:

Responsive Layouts Without Media Queries
Root font size equals 24px

And this is what user actually sees:

Responsive Layouts Without Media Queries
Root font size equals 16px

It especially affects people with vision problems, thus your page won’t be very accessible for them.

Of course, they can always zoom your page, but in this case it will affect other opened websites, which may not be supposed to be zoomed in.

BTW, the Lorem Ipsum site is a very “good” bad example of how non UX-friendly a page can look if you’re using pixels for fonts, margins, paddings etc.

If you're not familiar with the relative units like rem and vw, you should check this article on the MDN, where you can deep dive into CSS units and values: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Learn/CSS/Building_blocks/Values_and_units

Setup variables

To make it easier to build the layout, let's set up global variables first. Luckily, in CSS we have that opportunity. Since custom variables are subject to the cascade and inherit their value from their parent, we will define them on the :root pseudo-class, thus they can be applied to the whole HTML document.

:root {
  --primary-color: green;
  --primary-font: Helvetica, sans-serif;
  --text-font-size: clamp(1rem, 2.08vw, 1.5rem);
}

Looks pretty simple - we define a variable name, which must begin with a double hyphen (--). Then provide a variable value, which can be any valid CSS value.

Then we can use those variables for any element or even pseudo-class in the document using the var() function:

color: var(--primary-color);

For example, we can use our --primary-color variable for all the headings on the page like this:

h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, h6 {
  color: var(--primary-color);
}

Since the primary colour will use quite a lot of different elements on the page, it’s very handy to use the variable instead of writing each time the colour itself.

The last variable --text-font-size: clamp(1rem, 2.08vw, 1.5rem) might look odd: what’s the clamp and what’s it doing on the font size variable?

Dynamic font scaling

The clamp() CSS function clamps a middle value within a range of values between a defined minimum bound and a maximum bound.

You need to provide a minimum value (which is 1rem from the example above), a preferred value (2.08vw) and the maximum allowed value (1.5rem).

The most tricky part here is to set the preferred value. It should be in some viewport relative units (like vw or vh). Thus when a user resizes its browser or changes the device’s orientation the font size will scale proportionally.

I’ve made this formula for calculating the preferred value:

value = AMValue * remInPx / (containerWidth / 100)

Here comes an explanation, no panic:

AMValue - arithmetic mean, between the minimum and maximum allowed values in rem. In our example it equals (1rem 1.5rem) / 2 = 1.25rem

remInPx - default size of 1rem in pixels, depending on your design, usually it equals to 16px

containerWidth - the maximum width of your content container block (in pixels). We need to divide that value to 100 to get the 1% of the width. In the example it equals 960px.

So if you replace the arguments in that equation with real numbers you will get:

value = 1.25 \* 16 / (960 / 100) = 2.08

Let’s check how it will scale:

I know it’s not a perfect solution. Besides, we attach again to pixels, when calculating the preferred value. It’s just one of many possible options to make our fonts scale between viewports sizes.

You can use other CSS functions like min() or max(), or create a custom method to calculate the preferred value in the clamp() function.

I wrote an article about dynamic font size scaling, only for pixel units. It’s a bit outdated, but still you might find it helpful:

Dynamic font-size using only CSS3

Ok, enough of the fonts, let’s go further to the layout!

Layout with equal column width

Let’s start with some simple layout with 6 equal columns.

With media queries you need to write a bunch of extra CSS code to handle how they should wrap on different screen sizes. Like this:

/* by default we have 6 columns */
.column {
  float: left;
  width: calc(100% / 6);
}
/* decrease to 4 columns on the 1200px breakpoint */
@media screen and (max-width: 1200px) {
  .column {
    width: calc(100% / 4);
  }
}
/* decrease to 3 columns on the 1024px breakpoint */
@media screen and (max-width: 1024px) {
  .column {
    width: calc(100% / 3);
  }
}
/* finally, decrease to 2 columns for the viewport width less than or equal to 768px */
@media screen and (max-width: 768px) {
  .column {
    width: calc(100% / 2);
  }
}

Woah! That’s a lot of code, I must say! Wouldn't it be better to just make it scale automatically?

And here’s how, thanks to the CSS grid layout:

.row {
  display: grid;
  grid-template-columns: repeat( auto-fit, minmax(10em, 1fr) );
}

All we need to do is to set the parent block of our columns to be displayed as a grid. And then, create a template for our columns, using grid-template-columns property.

This is called RAM technique (stands for Repeat, Auto, Minmax) in CSS, you can read about it in more details here:

RAM Technique in CSS

In that property we use the CSS repeat() function.

The first argument is set to auto-fit, which means it FITS the CURRENTLY AVAILABLE columns into the space by expanding them so that they take up any available space. There’s another value for that argument: auto-fill. To understand the difference between them check this pen:

Also, I highly recommend to read this article from CSS tricks about auto sizing columns in CSS grid: https://css-tricks.com/auto-sizing-columns-css-grid-auto-fill-vs-auto-fit/

The second argument is using another function minmax(), which defines the size of each column. In our example each column should not be less than 10em and should be stretched to the remaining space.

Looks fine, but we have a problem - the number of columns can be bigger than 6!

To make a limit of columns, we need some custom formula again. But hey, it’s still in CSS! And it’s not that scary, basically, you just need to provide a gap for the grid, a minimal column width and the max number of columns.

Here’ the code:

.grid-container {

  /** * User input values. */
  --grid-layout-gap: 1em;
  --grid-column-count: 4;
  --grid-item--min-width: 15em;

  /** * Calculated values. */
  --gap-count: calc(var(--grid-column-count) - 1);
  --total-gap-width: calc(var(--gap-count) * var(--grid-layout-gap));
  --grid-item--max-width: calc((100% - var(--total-gap-width)) / var(--grid-column-count));

  display: grid;
  grid-template-columns: repeat(auto-fill, minmax(max(var(--grid-item--min-width), var(--grid-item--max-width)), 1fr));
  grid-gap: var(--grid-layout-gap);

}

And here’s what we achieve with that:

As you can see, we can use the relative values for the columns min width and gap, which makes this code like the perfect solution. Until they build the native CSS property for that, of course ?

Important notice! If you don't need a gap between columns, you need to set it to 0px or 0em, not just 0 (pure number). I mean you have to provide the units, otherwise the code won’t work.

I’ve found that solution on CSS tricks, so in case you want to dive deeper to how that formula works, here’s the original article about it: https://css-tricks.com/an-auto-filling-css-grid-with-max-columns/

Layout with different column width

The solution above works perfectly for the grids with equal width of the columns. But how to handle layouts with unequal columns? The most common example is a content area with a sidebar, so let’s work with this one.

Here’s a simple markup of the content area along with sidebar:

This is content

Grid Item 1
Grid Item 2
Grid Item 3
Grid Item 4

For the .content section let’s use the flex box layout:

.content {
  display: flex;
  flex-wrap: wrap;
  justify-content: space-between;
  gap: 1rem;
}

The flex-wrap property here is important and should be set as wrap in order to force the columns (sidebar and content area) stack under each other.

For the sidebar and content columns we need to set flex properties like grow and basis:

/* Sidebar */
.content > aside {
  border: 1px solid var( - primary-color);
  padding: var( - primary-padding);
  flex-grow: 1;
  flex-basis: 15em;
}

/* Content */
.content > article {
  border: 1px solid var( - primary-color);
  padding: var( - primary-padding);
  flex-grow: 3;
  flex-basis: 25em;
}

The flex-basis property sets the initial size of the flex item. Basically, it’s a minimum width which the flex item should have.

The flex-grow property sets the flex grow factor — similar to the proportion of the flex item compared to the other flex items. It’s a very rough and approximate explanation, to understand better the flex-grow property I highly recommend to read this article from CSS tricks: https://css-tricks.com/flex-grow-is-weird/

So if we set the flex-grow: 1 for the sidebar and flex-grow: 3 for the content area, that means the content area will take approximately three times more space than the sidebar.

I also added the grid section from the previous example to demonstrate that it works inside the flex layout as well.

Here’s what we have in the final result:

Stackable columns

It’s pretty common, when you have a grid layout where text comes next to image on one row and then in reverse order on the next row:

Responsive Layouts Without Media Queries

But when the columns become stacked you want them to be in a specific order, where text comes always before image, but they don’t:

Responsive Layouts Without Media Queries

To achieve that we need to detect somehow when the columns become stacked.

Unfortunately, it’s impossible (yet) to do that with pure CSS. So we need to add some JS code to detect that:

/**
* Detect when elements become wrapped
*
* @param {NodeList} items - list of elements to check
* @returns {array} Array of items that were wrapped
*/
const detectWrap = (items) => {
  let wrappedItems = [];
  let prevItem = {};
  let currItem = {};

  for (let i = 0; i  {
  const items = wrapper.querySelectorAll(":scope > *");

  // remove ".wrapped" classes to detect which items was actually wrapped
  cover.classList.remove("wrapped");

  // only after that detect wrap items
  let wrappedItems = detectWrap(items); // get wrapped items

  // if there are any elements that were wrapped - add a special class to menu
  if (wrappedItems.length > 0) {
    cover.classList.add("wrapped");
  }

};

The function addWrapClasses() accepts two arguments.

The first one is wrapper — it’s a parent element of the items which we should check whether they are wrapped (stacked) or not.

The second argument cover is an element to which we apply a special CSS class .wrapped. Using this class you can change your layout when the columns become stacked.

If you want to apply the .wrapped class directly to the wrapper element you can pass the same element as the second argument.

For better understanding my “wonderful” explanation please see the pen below, hope it will become more clear for you:

You can also use it to detect when the header menu should be collapsed into the burger. You can read about that case in my article here:

An Easy Way to Make an Auto Responsive Menu

Combining all together

Here’s a pen with all the techniques I mentioned in this article combined:

Final thoughts

I’ve used the techniques from this article in my recent project and it worked very well. The web pages look fine on every screen with no need to optimise them manually on multiple breakpoints.

Of course I will be lying if I tell you I didn’t use media queries at all. It all depends on the design and how flexible you can be with modifying page layout. Sometimes it’s much faster and simpler just to add a couple of breakpoints and then fix CSS for them. But I think eventually CSS media queries will be replaced by CSS functions like clamp() which allow developers to create responsive layouts automatically.


If you find this article helpful — don’t hesitate to like, subscribe and leave your thoughts in the comments ?


Read more posts on my Medium blog


Thanks for reading!

Stay safe and peace to you!

版本聲明 本文轉載於:https://dev.to/bogdanfromkyiv/responsive-layouts-without-media-queries-1e73?1如有侵犯,請聯絡[email protected]刪除
最新教學 更多>
  • 如何使用“ JSON”軟件包解析JSON陣列?
    如何使用“ JSON”軟件包解析JSON陣列?
    parsing JSON與JSON軟件包 QUALDALS:考慮以下go代碼:字符串 } func main(){ datajson:=`[“ 1”,“ 2”,“ 3”]`` arr:= jsontype {} 摘要:= = json.unmarshal([] byte(...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 如何將多種用戶類型(學生,老師和管理員)重定向到Firebase應用中的各自活動?
    如何將多種用戶類型(學生,老師和管理員)重定向到Firebase應用中的各自活動?
    Red: How to Redirect Multiple User Types to Respective ActivitiesUnderstanding the ProblemIn a Firebase-based voting app with three distinct user type...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 如何從PHP中的Unicode字符串中有效地產生對URL友好的sl。
    如何從PHP中的Unicode字符串中有效地產生對URL友好的sl。
    為有效的slug生成首先,該函數用指定的分隔符替換所有非字母或數字字符。此步驟可確保slug遵守URL慣例。隨後,它採用ICONV函數將文本簡化為us-ascii兼容格式,從而允許更廣泛的字符集合兼容性。 接下來,該函數使用正則表達式刪除了不需要的字符,例如特殊字符和空格。此步驟可確保slug僅包...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 如何克服PHP的功能重新定義限制?
    如何克服PHP的功能重新定義限制?
    克服PHP的函數重新定義限制在PHP中,多次定義一個相同名稱的函數是一個no-no。嘗試這樣做,如提供的代碼段所示,將導致可怕的“不能重新列出”錯誤。 但是,PHP工具腰帶中有一個隱藏的寶石:runkit擴展。它使您能夠靈活地重新定義函數。 runkit_function_renction_...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • C++成員函數指針正確傳遞方法
    C++成員函數指針正確傳遞方法
    如何將成員函數置於c [&& && && && && && && && && && &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&華儀的函數時,在接受成員函數指針的函數時,要在函數上既要提供指針又可以提供指針和指針到函數的函數。需要具有一定簽名的功能指針。要通過成員函數,您需要同時提供對象指針(此...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • Java中Lambda表達式為何需要“final”或“有效final”變量?
    Java中Lambda表達式為何需要“final”或“有效final”變量?
    Lambda Expressions Require "Final" or "Effectively Final" VariablesThe error message "Variable used in lambda expression shou...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • Python中何時用"try"而非"if"檢測變量值?
    Python中何時用"try"而非"if"檢測變量值?
    使用“ try“ vs.” if”來測試python 在python中的變量值,在某些情況下,您可能需要在處理之前檢查變量是否具有值。在使用“如果”或“ try”構建體之間決定。 “ if” constructs result = function() 如果結果: 對於結果: ...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • MySQL中如何高效地根據兩個條件INSERT或UPDATE行?
    MySQL中如何高效地根據兩個條件INSERT或UPDATE行?
    在兩個條件下插入或更新或更新 solution:的答案在於mysql的插入中...在重複鍵更新語法上。如果不存在匹配行或更新現有行,則此功能強大的功能可以通過插入新行來進行有效的數據操作。如果違反了唯一的密鑰約束。 實現所需的行為,該表必須具有唯一的鍵定義(在這種情況下為'名稱'...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 如何高效地在一個事務中插入數據到多個MySQL表?
    如何高效地在一個事務中插入數據到多個MySQL表?
    mySQL插入到多個表中,該數據可能會產生意外的結果。雖然似乎有多個查詢可以解決問題,但將從用戶表的自動信息ID與配置文件表的手動用戶ID相關聯提出了挑戰。 使用Transactions和last_insert_id() 插入用戶(用戶名,密碼)值('test','tes...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 如何為PostgreSQL中的每個唯一標識符有效地檢索最後一行?
    如何為PostgreSQL中的每個唯一標識符有效地檢索最後一行?
    postgresql:為每個唯一標識符提取最後一行,在Postgresql中,您可能需要遇到與在數據庫中的每個不同標識相關的信息中提取信息的情況。考慮以下數據:[ 1 2014-02-01 kjkj 在數據集中的每個唯一ID中檢索最後一行的信息,您可以在操作員上使用Postgres的有效效率: ...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • Async Void vs. Async Task在ASP.NET中:為什麼Async Void方法有時會拋出異常?
    Async Void vs. Async Task在ASP.NET中:為什麼Async Void方法有時會拋出異常?
    在ASP.NET async void void async void void void void void的設計無需返回asynchroncon而無需返回任務對象。他們在執行過程中增加未償還操作的計數,並在完成後減少。在某些情況下,這種行為可能是有益的,例如未期望或明確預期操作結果的火災和...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 編譯器報錯“usr/bin/ld: cannot find -l”解決方法
    編譯器報錯“usr/bin/ld: cannot find -l”解決方法
    錯誤:“ usr/bin/ld:找不到-l “ 此錯誤表明鏈接器在鏈接您的可執行文件時無法找到指定的庫。為了解決此問題,我們將深入研究如何指定庫路徑並將鏈接引導到正確位置的詳細信息。 添加庫搜索路徑的一個可能的原因是,此錯誤是您的makefile中缺少庫搜索路徑。要解決它,您可以在鏈接器命令中添...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 在JavaScript中如何並發運行異步操作並正確處理錯誤?
    在JavaScript中如何並發運行異步操作並正確處理錯誤?
    同意操作execution 在執行asynchronous操作時,相關的代碼段落會遇到一個問題,當執行asynchronous操作:此實現在啟動下一個操作之前依次等待每個操作的完成。要啟用並發執行,需要進行修改的方法。 第一個解決方案試圖通過獲得每個操作的承諾來解決此問題,然後單獨等待它們: c...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21
  • 在Python中如何創建動態變量?
    在Python中如何創建動態變量?
    在Python 中,動態創建變量的功能可以是一種強大的工具,尤其是在使用複雜的數據結構或算法時,Dynamic Variable Creation的動態變量創建。 Python提供了幾種創造性的方法來實現這一目標。 利用dictionaries 一種有效的方法是利用字典。字典允許您動態創建密鑰並...
    程式設計 發佈於2025-07-21

免責聲明: 提供的所有資源部分來自互聯網,如果有侵犯您的版權或其他權益,請說明詳細緣由並提供版權或權益證明然後發到郵箱:[email protected] 我們會在第一時間內為您處理。

Copyright© 2022 湘ICP备2022001581号-3